How we test
Who runs the tests
Tested and edited by Rachit Tiwari, Founder of ShortStack.tools
Every price check and hands-on test on this site is run by ShortStack.tools. ShortStack.tools was founded and is edited by Rachit Tiwari, who also signs off every test result before it is published.
How we check prices
- Every listed price is checked against the tool's official pricing page.
- We recheck prices on a rolling schedule, starting with the tools readers use most. Not every tool is rechecked on a fixed cycle.
- Where a pricing page has a monthly and a yearly toggle, we check both and say which one a price is for.
- We record whether a tool has a free plan, a free trial or neither, because these are not the same thing.
- Each tool page shows the date its price was last checked.
More detail is on how we check prices. What the rechecks found, including how many prices changed, is in our creator tool pricing report 2026.
The hands-on clipping test
To compare clipping tools fairly, we give each one the same video:
- Video: a public-domain NASA video from the NASA Image and Video Library, in which Expedition 71 astronauts Dyson and Williams talk with the Society of Women Engineers. We use minutes 1:00 to 11:00, at 1280x720 and 30 fps.
- Setup: each tool's free plan (or free trial where there is no free plan) with its default settings, in a desktop browser on a computer without a graphics card. If a maker gives us an upgraded account, the results say so (Klap, Nov 20, 2026: an account Klap upgraded from 100 to 300 clips).
- What we record: time to clips, clips found, clips exported for free, export resolution, any watermark (checked on exported frames, not on the preview), and whether an account or a card is required.
Where a tool could not take the file as it was, or needed a link instead of an upload, the tool page says what we changed. Tests ran from Oct 26 to Nov 20, 2026. Results for all tools side by side are in the same-video test. We also tried 2short.ai on Nov 7, 2026; its export was still queued after 20 hours, so it is not in the comparison.
| Tool | Date tested |
|---|---|
| Vizard | |
| Choppity | |
| quso.ai | |
| GPT-Video | |
| OpusClip | |
| Burncaps | |
| Klap |
The captions test
For caption tools we upload a 60-second clip, export the captions with the default settings, and count the word errors against a transcript we checked by hand. The Descript test used a 60-second clip from a history video instead of the NASA clip.
- Clip: minute 1 to minute 2 of the same public-domain NASA video, at 1280x720 and 30 fps. The first 6 seconds are silent, and our transcript has 118 words, including the names Roth, Doty and Suni.
- Word errors: every word a tool got wrong, left out or added, divided by the 118 words of our transcript. We read the subtitle file and check the burned-in captions on exported frames.
- Not counted: filler sounds (uh, um), which some tools write and others drop, and the first word of the next answer in the last half second of the clip, which is cut off. We started applying these two rules on Nov 15, 2026 and re-counted the earlier results where our notes list every error.
All caption results side by side are in the same-clip caption test.
| Tool | Date tested | Word errors |
|---|---|---|
| ZapCap | 0 of 118 words wrong, including the names Roth, Doty and Suni | |
| Descript | "Najm" (Nedjem), "Tauret" (Taweret), "Set Maat" (Set Ma'at) | |
| Checksub | 117 of 118 reference words matched (it wrote "How about us?" where our transcript has "how us?"); names Roth, Doty and Suni were right | |
| Zeemo | 1 of 118 words missed (the first word, "Station"); Roth, Doty and Suni right. | |
| Caption & Cut | 0% of words wrong (0 of 118): the burned-in captions had every word, including the names Roth, Doty and Suni and the number 26. | |
| Captions Generator | 0 of 118 words wrong. | |
| Captions | 0 of 118 words wrong in the editor preview; Roth, Doty, Suni and the number 26 were right. | |
| VEED | 1 of 118 words wrong (0.8%): "SUNY" for Suni. | |
| Caption Generator | 2 of 118 words wrong (1.7%): "How was?" for "how us?" and "Sunni" for Suni. | |
| Yap Audio to Text | 3 of 118 words wrong (2.5%): "Dodie" for Doty, "looked" for look and "SUNY" for Suni. | |
| Offline Captions | 4 of 118 words wrong (3.4%): "Rath" for Roth, "Doudy" for Doty, "on" for one and "SUNY" for Suni. | |
| Subclip | 7 of 118 words wrong (5.9%): left out "Station" and "the" before organization, and wrote "Rath" for Roth, "Doudy" for Doty, "How is" for "how us", "soon" for Suni and "this space program" for "the space program" | |
| Burncaps | 0 of 118 words wrong; Roth, Doty and Suni right |
The voice test
For AI voice tools we paste the same 68-word Shorts script into each tool, with the default English (US) voice, and time it from pressing Generate to audio ready.
- Script: written for the test, with a number (1,250), a year (2026), a brand (YouTube Shorts), a hard name (Nguyen), an abbreviation (AI), a question and an exclamation.
- Word errors: we transcribe each clip with two speech-to-text models on our own computer. A word counts as wrong only when both heard something else; case, punctuation and number format don't count.
- Also recorded: the free character limit, whether the free plan can download and in what format, any audio watermark, and the free plan's commercial-use terms quoted from the official page.
Each tool runs on its free option, from our own Windows computer on a home connection (Microsoft Edge), and we don't solve CAPTCHAs or "verify you are human" checks. Results are in the same-script voice test.
Independence
Paid placements and paid links are labeled "Sponsored", and affiliate links are marked rel="sponsored" with a note on the page that some links are affiliate links. Neither changes a test result or a ranking. Tool makers can email us to correct a fact, but test results are published as we found them. See editorial and disclosures for how listings work.
Corrections
If a price, plan or test result is wrong or out of date, tell us at hello@shortstack.tools through the contact page. We check the claim against the tool's own site, fix the page, and update the checked date.